Beyond Facebook, the fascist dystopia

At a workshop that we gave to a client recently, partner in crime Ivan Pope positioned social networks as follows (this isn't word for word, but I think it's true to Ivan's thinking and I'm sure he'll correct me if I'm wrong!):

MySpace is like an old-fashioned vision of the future: Heavy machinery; mechanical; steam-powered; clunky; and basically a bit broken.

And he described Facebook as the "fascist dystopia" of social networking, although looking at that Wikipedia definition, I think anti-utopia might be more appropriate, since Facebook tries hard to convey that its interests are with its population (users.)

So the question everyone's asking is: When will we get a truly democratic, open social network?

Part of the answer lies in social networks opening up more. TechCrunch has reports that Google is planning on using its social network Orkut as a basis for a Facebook-beating social networking platform that's much more open and able to integrate with other networks. A platform where you would be able to create applications that leverage the Orkut social network without having to build the application INSIDE of Orkut itself, like you do with Facebook.

This is potentially big news, but it only goes part of the way towards utopia because despite being more open the problem is that its still controlled by one company.

The thing is, I doubt very much that users will care. They certainly don't care about Facebook being a 'fascist dystopia' because its so much more open and flexible than anything they've had before. And I reckon they'll care even less about the lack of TRUE democracy on an even more open platform run by Google, a brand they probably already trust.

So does it really matter? I think it does. I think that social networking infrastructure and protocols need to be as open and free as the glue that already binds the Internet together: DNS; TCP/IP; HTTP; Email etc. To accept that control of what will be a key part of how we use the Net in the future resides with any one company just FEELS plain wrong.

What do you think?

Comments

[Alex Farran]

I'm pleased to see the moves towards a more open social graph. Google are being very cautious right now. I think that's just part of their general policy of not setting deadlines. Six Apart have been more forward in their commitment to open standards http://icanhaz.com/opensocialgraph

The standards are out there already. It just requires the will to use them. Ultimately openness benefits everybody. I look forward to being able to manage my social networks as easily as my RSS feeds.

[Ricardo]

I don't equate open with democracy in this context. I think it will be features embedded within a network that enable democratic usage - and by that I mean exposure of a persons views in an equal way..One network (badoo.com) allows each user to vote their profile into 1st place in the search results which, to me at least, is very democratic way to allowing users to gain an audience. And I guess democracy is only really about allowing equal access to the podium.

[Tom Nixon]

Cheers for the comment, Ricardo. What I would like to see is more democracy in how the network is 'governed'. It's the difference between being able to develop a website where you're free to do whatever you like, compared to a Facebook application where you have to agree to their terms and conditions.

[Geoff]

I totally agree with your comments. There is something "big brotherish" about Facebook. Why indeed should they have control over everybody's personal details? It's as if they've become a source of truth. Yes we need a more democratic, open (and open source) social networking platform. I've been approached a number of times to join Facebook and have refused for these reasons.

[Ash]

My problem with Facebook and MySpace is not the idea of social networking itself, but perhaps the way it works in the background. For marketeers, the data these sites collect about individuals is invaluable to the marketing industry I'm guessing that this data collection is the fundamental thing that gives such sites their enormous worth. Facebook, in particular can build up a very accurate demographical image of each user. This information can then be used to directly target the demographical group the user belongs to. I find this a little scary, personally.

Of course, data culling is not a new thing. What's perhaps the slightly iffy thing is that personal information collected by Facebook, etc, is controlled by one organisation. Giving that organisation great clout and power.

Creating a true commodity from information about you, the user.

[cheap puma shoes]

People like nails, once lost direction and began the resistance is lean, http://www.cheappumashoes.org/ then lose the value of their existence.

[mbt clearance]

The worst is that people often are wrong in their lives without being aware of barriers to ition,http://www.cheapmbtclearance.org/ so to get rid of those retards can understand the situation.

[mbt sandals]

If a person no opportunity to fight for their ideas, http://www.mbtshoes24.com/ then there is no need to claim.

[coach outlet]

As I look back on all that's happened.. growing up, growing together, changing you, changing me -- there were times when we dreamed together, when we laughed and cried together. As I look back on those days, I realize how much I truly miss you and how much I truly love you. The past may be gone forever.. and whatever the future holds, our today's make the memories of tomorrow. So, my lifetime friend, it is with all my heart that I send you my love, hoping that you'll always carry my smile with you, for all we have meant to each other and for whatever the future may hold.

[puma shoes sale]

Distance never separates two hearts that really care, for our memories span the miles and in seconds we are there. But whenever I start feeling sad cuz I miss you I remind myself how lucky I am to have someone so special to miss

[nike dunks]

In all large businesses, and people began to look like before you like a thousand police, as the time, http://www.nikedunks-high.com/ but during that time to seize the opportunity, as the Buddhist goddess of God.

[mbt outlet]

"Is that report." One of them went out after small answer, at this time, houses LiuFeng and another page left, LiuFeng freely asked that page, "from dawn, you how old this year, home." how parents LiuFeng remember this from xiao man is the home to the old saying LiuFeng repented, export, jin LiuFeng from xiao home with his mother, let his demanding from her darling, then when WangJin LiuFeng or benevolence, now she isn't this again in threatened him!

[coach outlet]

All of these informations are helpful.We believe there are much more wonderful topics would be here!

[Visvim Hockney]

He need to realize that not just about every present could be a blockbuster.

[mercurial vapor]

The final clearance most drastic hundred and Qin Chu. Pains were no live,the more a thousand hardships can swallow Wu.

[cheap puma shoes]

In terms of talent but by its very nature is the cause,just love the work process.

[Facebook Application Development]

its great if you want to see beyond you have to maximize your vision and thinking level as well.

[nike r4 shox sale]

Until the weather evens out or we just admit it's never coming, perhaps these beautiful time-lapse videos nike shox shoes will bring you the the same ahhhh it did for me. http://www.shoxclearance.com

[Facebook Business Pages]

Vision is the must.If you have a vision then you do somethings.

[replica chanel bags]

No one likes sunny days, the heart to tell people this sentence in the rain, rainy day to be a portrayal of a bad http://www.allbrandbag.com/ mood.http://www.chanelbags4sale.com/

[ugg boots sale]

Dad will take the time to hold each time I kissed and pro

[Facebook Developers]

If you want to do something then you need to make your vision and mission statement..

[replica chanel handbags]

have a nice day

[UGG UK Sale]

Very useful article for me, there is more information I have is very important. Thank you! I'm glad you could get out of it to share with us.

[coach outlet online]

Physicians of all men are most happy; most good success so ever they have, the world proclaimth,
and what faults they commit, the earth coverth.
Francis Quarles, British poet